Carrier Furnace Reviews – 2020 Picks

| Last Updated: February 28, 2021

If you are looking to invest in a furnace, you should probably consider one by Carrier. 

It is the brand that has modernized the industry with its outstanding inventions. And ever since then, it has only provided its users with top-quality products and nothing less. Each of the furnaces manufactured by Carrier is known to provide ideal functionality and design.

If you don’t know which product to choose for yourself, let us help you out.

How Does Carrier Compare to the Competition?

Carrier is known to be a very tough competitor on the market. Its products are second to none, and it succeeds in being the users’ choice over a number of other products. Here is how it compares to its competition in the market:

Durability

Durability is a standard feature that everyone looks for. While every other product on the market will offer you some level of durability, none of them come close to the reliability and durability that carrier offers. 

Energy-Efficient

Products by Carrier do come at a slightly greater cost than other standard market products, but it benefits you in the longer run. Their functionality is highly energy-efficient and makes their use cost-efficient as well. 

Technologically Advanced

Carrier has moved ahead in the race of technology and ensures that all its products are advanced in that aspect as well. It produces products that are compatible with our high tech lifestyle. 

Trane vs. Carrier Furnace

Trane is known to be one of the strongest competitors that Carrier has in the industry. Products by both brands are considered to be on the same tier and fall within the same price range.

While Carrier products may not be as energy-efficient as Trane, they do provide better compatibility with smart homes and Wi-Fi and are also known to allow easier installation and maintenance.

Carrier vs. Lennox Furnace

When comparing furnaces by Carrier and Lennox, products by the former have the advantage of being slightly cheaper than those offered by the latter. 

Furthermore, finding replacement parts for a Lennox furnace is a lot harder than it is to do so for Carrier furnaces.

The durability and reliability of Carrier furnaces beat that of Lennox by a considerable measure.

Bryant vs. Carrier Furnace

Products by Bryant are a lot cheaper than that by Carrier. But that is because Carrier furnaces are usually of better quality and build than Bryant. The efficiency of Bryant furnaces may not be up to the mark, though. The one advantage that Bryant has over Carrier is easy installation.

Rheem vs. Carrier Furnace

It would be right to say that there isn’t a difference in quality between the furnaces manufactured by either brand. Carrier is known to offer better terms of warranty than Rheem and also a lot more energy-efficient than Rheem, giving it the upper hand in the industry.

Comparison of the Best Carrier Furnaces

Looking at different products may give you an idea of what you want for yourself, but you can never make a perfect choice just by viewing them individually. What you need is a side by side comparison, so you have a better idea of which product you need to invest in. To help you out, here’s a comparison chart of the best Carrier furnaces.

Model Name

Unit Size 

Energy Efficiency (SEER)

Home Sq. Ft.

Condenser Fan Motor

Cost of Unit Only

Installation Cost

Carrier Infinity 98 59MN7

60,000 - 120,000 BTU 

98.5% AFUE

2,400 to 3,000 

Single

$2,650

$5,589

Carrier Comfort 92 59SC2

40,000 - 120,000 BTU

92.1% AFUE

2,400 to 3,000

Single

$1,252

$2,635

Carrier Comfort 95 59SC5

26,000 to 140,000 BTU

96.5% AFUE

2,400 to 3,000

Single

$1,575

$3,289

Carrier Performance 96 59TP6

40,000 to 120,000 BTU

96.5% AFUE

2,400 to 3,000

Single

$1,644

$3,600

Carrier Infinity 96 59TN6

60,000 to 120,000 BTU

96.7% AFUE

2,400 to 3,000

Single

$1,728

$5,589

Quick Take: Best Carrier Furnaces

These are our recommendations for the best Carrier furnaces:

  1. Carrier Infinity 98 59MN7
  2. Carrier Comfort 92 59SC2
  3. Carrier Comfort 95 59SC5

Review of the Best Carrier Furnaces

Now that you have an idea of how products by Carrier compare with those of its competition and its own, it is time to shed further light on all our top picks. We have listed and reviewed these products so you can pick the one that has all the features that you’re looking for.

PROS

  • Capable of operating steadily at lower capacities for a longer period of time
  • Features an adaptable speed technology that allows Greenspeed intelligence
  • Equipped with a blower that can operate at different speeds according to need
  • Provides users with an energy-efficient performance that makes it cost-effective
  • Designed with a modulation gas valve that can adapt to the heating needs of the space it is installed in

CONS

  • Users may find the unit to be a little noisy
  • No warranty available for parts of the product

Why it Stands Out to Us

This product stands to be our top choice for a great number of reasons. But it has one feature that makes it stand apart from the rest: the blower. It may be one of the basic components of the furnace, but its variable-speed functionality makes it ideal for all those users looking to boost SEER efficiency

The blower is optimized to work at not just one or two, but a great number of speeds. It is, therefore, capable of adapting to the needs of the space where it is installed, with absolutely no trouble at all.

Bottom Line

Looking for the best large-sized furnace for your home? This product is the one for you. It has all the right features to provide the ideal functionality for all the plus-sized rooms. Its top-quality build and high-end features will ensure that you experience nothing less than the best.

PROS

  • Users can opt to purchase an extended warranty for labor 
  • Stainless-steel secondary heat exchanger ensures a better level of durability
  • Single-stage operation of the product ensures a higher efficiency while operating
  • 20 years limited warranty on the heat exchanger to ensure absolute customer satisfaction
  • Equipped with an aluminized steel clamshell-style primary heat exchanger that allows a better functionality

CONS

  • Operating the unit may be a little tricky
  • May not be as reliable as other similar products

Why it Stands Out to Us

There is a whole list of reasons why we chose this product over a number of others to be on this list. The reason that tops the list and makes it stand apart from the rest is the outstanding warranty that comes with this furnace. The 20-year long warranty on the heat exchanger ensures that you enjoy the functionality of this product for a very long time. 

Very few other products, if any, come with warranties of such extended time periods. This goes to show that the company has confidence in the build and quality of the product. So at the end of the day, you can be assured that you are investing in a durable and quality product.

Bottom Line

This unit may be the second on the list, but only by a small margin. Its functionality and quality of build is no lesser than any other product and will be sure to leave you satisfied. No feature of this furnace by Carrier will leave you dissatisfied once you get the hang of it.

Best for the Money:
Carrier Comfort 95 59SC5

PROS

  • If registered on time, the heat exchanger has a lifetime limited warranty
  • Available in a wide range of capacities, making it an ideal pick for all room sizes
  • Features a pilot-free PowerHeat ignition that makes the product easier to operate
  • ECM blower motor that functions on multiple speeds to adapt to the needs of the room
  • Secondary heat exchanger designed with stainless steel for better functionality and durability

CONS

  • Users may need extra help for installation
  • No Bluetooth thermostat included with the product

Why it Stands Out to Us

This product has the obvious advantage of being considerably cheaper than other furnaces by Carrier. But that is not all that it has to offer for its users. Along with its affordable price range, it offers its users a great number of incentives that allow users to pick this product over others with great ease. 

Out of all the features that this product offers, what we absolutely love is how quietly it functions. The lack of noise produced by this furnace makes it ideal for large and small-sized homes alike where noise disturbances are always unwelcome, regardless of the source.

Bottom Line

Small home? No problem. Big home? Still no problem. This high-end furnace by Carrier is available for users at a wide range of capacities, making it perfect for all homes. Its price may vary with the capacity but still allows it to be cheaper than other products on the market.

Best Carrier Gas Furnace:
Carrier Performance 96 59TP6

PROS

  • Provides enhanced sound reduction with a fully insulated cabinet
  • Features a two-speed inducer motor that allows it to be more energy efficient
  • Two-stage gas valve provides better functionality than a single-stage valve design
  • Equipped with an ECM blower motor that works with variable speeds and constant torque
  • Allows a flexible installation which could be with an up-flow, downflow or even horizontal

CONS

  • Not as durable as other similar products
  • Terms for warranty are not as good as those offered for other products

Why it Stands Out to Us

Carrier has a lot of gas furnaces to offer for its users. But this product, in particular, is better than all the others due to its outstanding energy efficiency. Gas furnaces are known to consume more energy than other furnaces. This may make their use a lot more expensive, even though the product itself may not cost as much. 

While the quality of build and functionality may be the same as other gas furnaces, the cost-effectiveness it provides with the energy-efficient operation makes it our top choice in gas furnaces. 

Bottom Line

Looking for the best gas furnace available? You simply can’t go wrong with this product by Carrier. It has all the features that one would look for in a gas furnace. Its high efficiency, along with its ideal price range, makes it an ideal product for anyone and will make it your favorite as well. 

Best Carrier High-Efficiency Furnace:
Carrier Infinity 96 59TN6

PROS

  • With the variable-speed blower, users get greater control over the temperature
  • Also provides an element of better dehumidification during the summer season
  • Equipped with an air filter cabinet that simply allows you to breathe in fresher air
  • Provides a heating efficiency of up to 96.7% AFUE which is greater than a number of products
  • Backed by an impeccable intelligent Infinity control that allows greater efficiency of the product

CONS

  • Installation may prove to be a little time-consuming
  • Warranty not as good as that offered by other similar products

Why it Stands Out to Us

Why did we choose this product over so many others? The answer is simple: because of its impressive Infinity control. This unique technology is what allows the furnace to function consistently at lower temperatures for longer time periods. This allows its functionality to be a lot more energy-efficient than other standard products available on the market. 

Since the product consumes a lot less energy than other similar products, it provides users with a cost-efficient functionality that is simply outstanding. A better functionality, with a lower amount to pay, is what you sign up for with this product. Such a functionality definitely makes this product worth the investment. 

Bottom Line

This product may be the last one on the list, but we assure you that its functionality is just as good as that of our top product. With the energy-efficient performance, you will be able to forgive the little lack of warranty that it comes with. With a cost-efficient performance and adaptive functionality, what more can you ask for?

What Kind of Warranty Does Carrier Offer?

When buying any sort of product, its warranty serves as an important aspect that needs to be considered closely, to ensure a good experience with the product in the future. Carrier understands the importance of granting a suitable warranty for the product in order to ensure customer satisfaction. 

Warranties offered by Carrier, on its products, is more or less the same as that offered by other high-end brands in the industry. You need to register the warranty for the product that you purchase from the brand. And this has to be done within a given amount of time. If you fail to register in the allotted time, you won’t be able to claim the warranty, later on, be it on the whole product or specific parts.

The heat exchanger warranty that is offered by Carrier is better than that offered by other competing brands. However, the labor warranty is not included, unless paid for separately. It is advisable to purchase an extended warranty offered by the brand, be it on parts or labor since it proves to be beneficial.

Who is Carrier?

In the world of heating, air-conditioning, and refrigerants, Carrier is known to be a leading brand. It was found by Willis Carrier, in the early 20th century, when he revolutionized the air conditioning system. He invented modern air conditioning and ended some of the greatest challenges faced by mankind at the time. 

With the modern air conditioning system, a huge number of industries were able to progress in ways they never foresaw. Furthermore, the advanced air conditioning system served to enhance global productivity and improve health and personal comfort.

So when we speak of Carrier, we speak of a quality brand that not only changed the air-conditioning system as the world knew it at some point but managed to grow over the years, making itself one of the leading brands in the industry.

Conclusion

Carrier is one of the brands that you will simply never regret investing in. With the outstanding functionality of their products, the impeccable quality of build, and satisfying terms of the warranty, you will be sure to find a product that is absolutely perfect according to your needs and requirements. All you need to do is consider the right features and pick one that checks all the boxes on your list.

People Also Ask

While there is no doubt that products by Carrier are the absolute best, you may still have other questions regarding the furnaces offered by the brand. In order to help you clear all your doubts, we have answered some of the most frequently asked questions in order to help you make a better choice.

Where is the Model Number on a Carrier Furnace?

A lot of users find themselves having trouble locating the model number on their Carrier furnace when needed. This is because it is not placed anywhere in plain sight. The model number is usually present on the sticker that is attached to the inside of the product. You will have to remove the front door and find it on the top left corner.

Where is the Limit Switch on a Carrier Furnace?

A limit switch is one of the most important features of a furnace. The location of the limit switch on a Carrier furnace usually varies from one product to another. In general, it is usually found in the hot-air supply plenum. This is present right above the combustion chamber of the furnace.

How to Remove Condensate Trap on Carrier Furnace

Removing the condensate trap is easy if you can identify the control box. Once you have released the control box, you will find the condensate trap. The trap has four pipes connected to it. Three of these are on the top and one on the bottom. All you need to do is disconnect the pipes and pull the condensate trap out.

How to Reset a Carrier Furnace

If you find yourself needing to reset your Carrier furnace, but do not know how to do so, do not worry. It is actually pretty simple. You just need to locate the raised red button present at the center of the flame roll-out switch. Pressing and releasing the button will allow it to be reset.

How Much is a Carrier Furnace?

The cost of Carrier furnaces varies from product to product. The price varies, given the design of the product and its size. If you want a general estimate, then these products can range anywhere from $1,399 to $5,000, depending on the different features that they offer.

How Long Will a Carrier Furnace Last?

Carrier is known to provide its users with reliable and top-quality products. If you invest in a furnace by the brand, you can rest assured that its durability will allow it to last for a considerably long time. Furnaces by Carrier are known to last around 20-30 years. If it is taken good care of, it may even last over 40 years. 

Where Are Carrier Furnaces Made?

Carrier is a brand that has spread its manufacturing over a wide area. Different products of the brand are produced at different locations and distributed all over the country. When it comes to the top-quality furnaces by the brand, both residential and commercial, they are made in the site at Indianapolis. 

My name is Bob Wells and I am a retired HVAC tech from Washington state. I am currently retired and no longer do much with HVAC, however, I feel like I have a lot of knowledge in the subject and I wanted to create a website where I could talk about what I've learned and help upcoming HVAC techs. Find more info about me and HVAC Training 101.