Coleman Furnace Reviews – 2020 Guide

| Last Updated: March 10, 2021

With winter season knocking on our doors, families are on the hunt for a good-quality and high-functioning furnace.

In this article, we have rounded up the best furnace models from Coleman so that you can cozy up in the warmth of your home.

So, without any further ado, let’s get started. 

Who is Coleman?

Coleman came into being 120 years ago, and it began its journey by manufacturing and selling lanterns and camp stoves. After decades of staying in this industry, Coleman moved to manufacture HVAC products in 1958. They now have headquarters in York, Pennsylvania, and are owned by York International Corporation. 

The company is known for its dependable and reliable products that perform with great efficiency and have superior performance levels. The heating and cooling products that Coleman offers include air conditioners, heat pumps, furnaces, and packaged units. 

What Makes Coleman Furnaces Stand Out From the Competition?

Many brands in the HVAC industry have been operating for a long time, but Coleman has been functioning as a business since the 1900s. Its life-long experience gives them a competitive edge over other brands, as it has more knowledge and know-how of HVAC products. 

Along with the experience, Coleman offers exceptional warranties in terms of the limited parts as well as labor warranties. All Coleman furnaces have a lifetime heat exchanger limited warranty and 90-day labor warranty to fix any issues that may arise. This ensures confidence in the durability and performance of their products. 

Types of Furnaces By Coleman

There are several different types of furnaces that are available in the market, and Coleman offers unique models to all its customers.

The two categories offered include residential gas furnaces and commercial gas furnaces. 

Commercial Gas Furnaces

This category includes the “Light Commercial” furnace, which is a reliable model fulfilling your heating needs. It has a high capacity and is designed specifically for industrial use.

Residential Gas Furnaces

These are more suitable for homes and residential areas. The different models of residential gas furnaces are mentioned below.

You can decide which one suits your needs better by taking a glance at the options available by Coleman:

Coleman MM9E

Echelon Series

These are energy-star certified furnaces that provide higher efficiency and performance as compared to other models. They are equipped with EcoTrak comfort technology, which ensures the accurate operating cycle according to your locality. The efficiency ratings of these models are up to 80% AFUE. 

LX-Series Gas Furnaces

There are ten different models in this series, and each of these models consists of a two-stage burner and ECM motor, which keeps the warmth and temperature consistent and ensures energy efficiency. The furnaces in this series offer energy-efficiency of up to 95% AFUE and are also Energy-Star qualified. 

Comforteer Series Gas Furnaces

The TG9S and TG8S models offered by Coleman are high-efficiency and incredibly impressive. They also have PSC fan motors and exceptional airflow to enhance air quality and maintain consistency in the temperature in the room. The energy efficiency in these models is 95.5% AFUE. 

Quick Take: Best Coleman Furnaces

These are our recommendations for the best Coleman furnaces:

  1. Coleman MM9E
  2. LX Series TM9E
  3. LX Series TL9E

Review of the Best Coleman Furnaces

Let’s now take a look at some of the most sought-after Coleman furnaces that you should consider purchasing:

Best Overall:
Coleman MM9E

PROS

  • Reliable and extra-safe construction
  • 95% AFUE, which makes it energy-efficient
  • Complies with Energy Star and is highly efficient
  • Impressive blower motor for exceptional comfort
  • Durable front door panel with an industry-leading warranty

CONS

  • Doesn’t work on oil

What Recent Buyers Report

With an efficiency rating of 95% AFUE, this furnace is super powerful and well-designed. It is equipped with some of the most highly advanced features that you would want in a high-quality furnace, which is why it is sought-after by most users. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

If you want the best warmth and cozy experience, do not hesitate to check out the Coleman MM9E model. This highly reliable and superior furnace aims to heat up your home within minutes, making your house warm and toasty. It is also equipped with rugged steel heat exchangers for a durable and more long-lasting finish.

Along with that, Coleman comes with an advanced motor blower that reduces the need for chimney venting and provides excellent comfort. The durable finish on the exterior also makes the product more durable and less prone to rust and corrosion. 

Bottom Line

On the hunt for the best Coleman furnace to warm up your home on cold and freezing nights? This model has you covered. With its superior construction and high-end quality, it ticks all boxes for a reliable experience.

Runner-up:
LX Series TM9E

PROS

  • Indoor air quality options available
  • Industry-leading warranty provided with the furnace
  • 95% AFUE efficient to produce more heat with less cost
  • No need for a chimney with its induced combustion design
  • Extra-safe and reliable furnace with 100% shut-off main valve

CONS

  • Not as powerful as other Coleman models 

What Recent Buyers Report

Coming with a ten-year parts warranty, this furnace comes with a compact design and built-in diagnostics that provide convenience for all homes. It is also super powerful and has a highly efficient ECM motor that heats the room in minutes, a feature most users loved. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

The main reason why this model stands out is its superior quality and exceptional design. This furnace is one of the most compact models with up to 95% AFUE, which makes it more efficient and cost-saving. It also comes with a five-year assurance warranty pledge.  

Furthermore, it serves as the perfect machine to provide warmth and comfort on cold nights. Since it is equipped with a single-stage burner and ECM motor, the hot air dissipates easily and quickly across the rooms. The heat exchanger is also designed to be durable and stays brand new for years.

Bottom Line

Designed with high-quality materials, this energy-efficient model aims to reduce costs and provide more heat with its 95% AFUE rating. It is also super impressive in terms of performance and is loved by many users worldwide. 

Best for the Money:
LX Series TL9E

PROS

  • Produces super-low harmful emissions
  • Stainless-steel design that prevents corrosion
  • 20% reduced fuel costs due to its high AFUE ratings
  • Highly efficient ECM fan motor for exceptional comfort
  • Fully insulated blower with optimization from Energy Star

CONS

  • Not as technologically advanced as higher-end models

What Recent Buyers Report

Families on a budget who wanted a high-quality furnace without a hefty price tag found this model to be quite impressive. It is sturdy, durable, and provides the right level of comfort and warmth to the home, making your experience satisfying and hearty. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

For a low price, this furnace packs a lot of interesting features. It is equipped with an advanced burner technology that reduces emissions by 65% as compared to the older models. It also comes with a single-stage burner that has a highly efficient ECM motor for superior comfort. 

It is also designed to ensure exceptional durability and satisfying warmth and coziness. It is also impressively super energy-efficient, and the users have found this furnace to be comparable to higher-end models. Overall, this fuel-saving and efficient furnace should be on top of your list if you’re looking for a cheaper alternative.

Bottom Line

Searching for a furnace that has a lifetime warranty but doesn’t cost a lot? Look no further; this model is equipped with all the right features to make your winter nights much more warm and cozy. 

Best Coleman Mobile Home Furnace:
Comforteer Series TG9S

PROS

  • Complies with Energy Star and is highly efficient
  • Built-in shut off controls for reliability and safety
  • High-quality blower motor for exceptional comfort
  • Durable construction with corrosion-resistant surface
  • One of the highest energy efficiency ratings of fuel costs up to 35%

CONS

  • MBH is not as high as other models

What Recent Buyers Report

This impressive furnace is designed with the highest energy efficiency ratings, which ensures a satisfying and amazing customer experience. It comes with shut off controls and built-in diagnostics for better control and safety and reduces fuel costs up to 35%, which makes it a bang for the buck. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

The TG9S from the Comforter series is definitely one of the best mobile home furnaces that you can get in the market right now. It’s efficient, both in terms of use and energy, and is designed with superior quality materials that makes it last for a very long time. Moreover, the technology implanted in this furnace is very powerful, and it is super convenient and easy to use.

Along with those features, this furnace is also compact, which means it can be easily transported from one place to another whenever needed. 

Bottom Line

On the hunt for a mobile furnace for your home? This one comes with all the features you will need to provide the right amount of warmth to your home whenever needed. It is also reliable for a long period of time and is perfectly safe to use.

Best Coleman Gas Furnace:
Echelon™ Series CP9C

PROS

  • Built-in diagnostics for safety and reliability
  • Ten-year complete assurance warranty pledge
  • Made with high-quality materials to ensure durability
  • Condensing design to extract more heat and cut costs
  • Equipped with a variable-speed blower which is quiet and smooth in operation

CONS

  • Not suitable for smaller homes

What Recent Buyers Report

For a supreme and luxurious experience, this furnace is recommended by many users. It is reliable, sturdy, and packs a lot of amazing features. It is also 98% AFUE, which makes it highly energy-efficient and cost-saving. It is also super safe to use and has an impressive performance. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

For people who are on the hunt for a powerful furnace to heat their home in a short span, this is the best gas furnace that you can find in the market. It is fully insulated, and its technologically advanced interior and exterior make its operation quiet and smooth.

Moreover, the heat exchanger is designed with an efficient condensing feature to extract more heat without increasing costs. It also comes with an integrated ClimaTrak system that is tailored to fit the exact climate needs of your home.

Bottom Line

The CP9C model is one of the most technologically advanced gas furnaces out there, and it is designed to ensure maximum comfort for the user. If you want the best gas furnace from Coleman, do check this one out. 

Best Coleman Electric Furnace:
Coleman EBE/EBU

PROS

  • Enclosed in a safe and durable closed compact
  • Highly reliable as it is not powered by gas or oil
  • Serves as an air handler and an electric furnace
  • Efficiently provides electrical heating in the room
  • Even and consistent airflow throughout the space

CONS

  • Way too large to fit in a low-ceiling home

What Recent Buyers Report

Users who wanted a large furnace that works on electricity highly recommend this model. It has a multi-speed blower that can handle electric heating as well as cooling. It is more apt for manufacturing housing situations and is highly safe and reliable to use. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

With its sleek design and powerful features, this furnace stands out as a highly technologically advanced and convenient model. It is preferred by users who do not want to risk buying an oil or gas furnace, and it comes in a durable and strong exterior. 

Added to that, the furnace also comes with built-in diagnostics to ensure that the heat remains in the room for a long time and that safety is ensured the whole time the furnace is on. Its modern design is also aimed at saving energy, and it is more energy-efficient compared to older models. 

Bottom Line

For users who want a cooler and heater at the same time, this electrical furnace is highly recommended to them. It comes with many impressive features that will enhance your home's comfort level and make you feel cozier in the winters.

Comparison Overview

Let’s now compare Coleman with some competitors in the market:

Coleman Furnace vs Carrier

Coleman utilizes an EcoTrak system to create a climate cycle that best suits your house. This is one of the most unique and innovative features that you will not find in Carrier furnaces. It also uses the WhisperDrive comfort system to ensure quiet operation.

Carrier uses humidity control on its furnaces to improve air quality and provide clean and refreshing air throughout the winters without making the climate sticky or irritable. It also uses insulated cabinets to ensure smooth and quiet operation of the furnace models. 

Revolve vs Coleman Furnace

Revolve furnaces are mainly produced for the manufactured housing industry, and they have several features in their furnaces, such as a multi-speed down-flow blower. Their furnaces are also up to 95% AFUE energy-efficient, which makes them quite cost-cutting and impressive. 

Coleman has a modulating burner design that comes with a variable-speed ECM fan motor. Their furnaces range from 90-98% AFUE energy efficient and are equipped with WhisperDive and EcoTrek technologies to make them stand out more and boost their performance.

Coleman Furnace vs Goodman

Goodman uses several unique, innovative technologies, such as a tubular heat exchanger with wrinkle bend technology, which is designed to maintain durability and promote heat transfer. The top features also include a multi-speed PSC blower and ECM blower to enhance airflow and provide heat consistently.

Coleman uses other technologies to make sure that users have maximized comfort and value for money. The cabinets are insulated, and the furnaces are equipped with EcoTrek and WhisperDive, as opposed to the wrinkle bend technologies used by Goodman.

Coleman Furnace Troubleshooting 

Users may face some minor issues with the furnace, whether it's regarding installation or its performance. This section guides you on how you can fix those issues. Here are some of the most common furnace problems that may arise:

Furnace Not Heating 

The main issue that arises is that the furnace is not heating up properly. In order to fix this, you must first check your furnace’s igniter to see if it’s cracked and faulty.

Noisy Furnace

Check the blower wheel to see if its screws are properly tightened or not. The chances are the wheel may be damaged, or the screws are loose.

Coleman Furnace Blower Motor Problems

There may be several issues that you might face with the blower motor. If it is burned out, you need to replace it altogether. If it hums, then you should check if the fan of the blower motor is spinning freely. If the capacitor of the Coleman is defective, it may not run or be noisy. 

Coleman Furnace Error Codes

There are three-colored lights that flash, of which red indicates something wrong with the furnace's operations. Green indicates normality, red has different meanings, depending on the number of times it flashes, and amber means normal operation with a request for heat.

How to Read Blinking Code on a Coleman Furnace

One blinking red light means that the gas valve needs to be checked, while two and three flashes mean that the pressure switch is immobile from the open position. Four flashes mean that the limit switch is faulty, five means the rollout switch needs to be checked, and six means the pressure switch cycle has been locked out. 

Coleman Furnace Error Code 4

Four red flashes mean that there is an error with the limit switch, and it has been stuck while opened. You need to check whether the filter is dirty or not or if the duct has been improperly sized. There can also be an issue with the blower motor. 

Combustion Air Switch Failed to Close on Coleman Furnace

Check if all the tubes are cleaned out and running. If it still doesn’t work, you might need to replace it. 

Coleman Furnace Pilot Light Keeps Going Out

One of the most common reasons for this is that the thermocouple is set a longer distance from the pilot light. It should be adjusted in a way such that the pilot light gives a flame of at least two inches long.

Coleman Furnace Limit Switch Stuck Open

This could be because the filter is dirty or because the duct is sized improperly. 

How to Check Coleman Furnace Lighter

If the furnace burner keeps malfunctioning or shutting on and off, you might need to check its air filters. Overheating and other malfunctioning issues can occur if the furnace burners aren’t cleaned out properly. The air can be restricted, and the furnace won’t stay lit if not cleaned out.

Coleman Furnace No Fault Light When On Lowest Setting

The pilot light can be one of the main reasons why the furnace doesn’t ignite. If the igniter or sensor is dirty, it needs to be cleaned in order for the pilot light to work.

Tips Every Coleman Furnace Owner Should Know

Here are some of the main things that every user of Coleman furnaces must know and educate themselves on:

How to Shut Off a Coleman Furnace

Using the electric service panel, find the off button on the switch and click on it. Your furnace will be turned off. 

Where is the Pilot Light on a Coleman Furnace?

On a Coleman furnace, you will find the pilot light on the bottom of the model. There will also be a gas valve with on, off, and other pilot settings. 

Where is the Limit Switch on a Coleman Furnace?

The manual reset switch is available on the left side of the Coleman furnace. It also comes with an upper limit switch if you want to manually reset it. There’s also a lower limit switch in case you want to do it automatically. 

How to Light a Coleman Furnace

Firstly, you must find the pilot light, a small burner that you will find at the furnace's bottom entrance. If it is on, you will be able to notice that it has a small flame. Turn off the gas furnace and wait for the gas to vent out of the furnace completely. Once that is done, relight the pilot light with the help of the ignition button.

What Size Filter Does a Coleman Furnace Take?

The filter sizes of a Coleman furnace depends on the size of the model. Some of the models have a nominal size of 16x20x5 inches, while some measure 20x20x5 inches.

How to Start a Coleman Furnace With Ignition Switch

If the furnace has an electronic igniter, never ignite the furnace manually. Always call a professional for this job. But if you want to reset the furnace switch, you should know that a Coleman furnace comes with two temperature switches that protect it from overheating. 

How to Clean a Heat Pump Coil On a Coleman Furnace

First, you must wipe the condenser coils with the help of its special cleaner. You can even use soap and water for the job. Use a hose or shower to wash it. Use a fin comb to make sure there are no bent condenser fins. Put the top grill back on with the heat pump cover back into place.

Conclusion 

Coleman provides a wide variety of products and types of furnaces to its consumers. It is known for its efficient energy-saving furnaces and customer service. The warranties provided are also market-competitive. Hopefully, this guide proved to be useful for you, and good luck finding the right furnace!

People Also Ask

If you still have some questions or concerns regarding Coleman furnaces, you can look at the following frequently asked questions to get further insight into your queries or concerns. Let’s go over some of the main questions asked by users:

Where Are Coleman Furnaces Made?

Coleman is a subsidiary of York and Johnson Controls Company, and it has its manufacturing headquarters in Norman, Oklahoma, and Wichita, Kansas as well. All the products are manufactured and designed here.

Who Makes Coleman Furnaces?

Coleman furnaces are manufactured by Johnson Controls, who also produces York furnaces. They have headquarters in Kansas and Oklahoma. 

Comforteer Series TG9S

Who Owns Coleman?

The parent company of Coleman is Johnson Controls.

How Long Has Coleman Been Around?

Many brands in the HVAC industry have been operating for a long time, but Coleman has been functioning as a business since the 1900s, which adds up to a whopping 120 years. Their life-long experience gives them a competitive edge over other brands, as they have more knowledge and know-how of HVAC products. 

Why Are Coleman Furnaces so Popular?

Their patented designs and innovative technologies make Coleman’s furnace some of the most popular and sought-after furnaces in America. They are also durable and energy-saving, which are both important features users look for.

What Kind of Warranty Does Coleman Offer?

Coleman offers its customers a ten-year warranty for all the products it sells. It also provides a limited lifetime warranty for the heat exchanger, and it also provides optional furnace replacement as well. However, product registration is required.

Are Coleman Furnaces Any Good?

No matter your budget, you will always find something worthy of purchasing at Coleman because it offers some of the most energy-saving and budget-friendly furnaces in the market. 

How Long Does a Coleman Furnace Last?

If you have installed the furnace using the help of professionals, you can expect it to last for about 20-25 years. This is the maximum lifespan, considering maintenance and service has been done regularly. 

How Much is a Coleman Furnace?

You can expect to purchase a Coleman furnace between the range of $2500 and $4500, inclusive of installation charges. However, different HVAC technicians can charge around $500-$1000 for the installation of the furnace.

Are York And Coleman The Same Company?

Coleman and York are subsidiaries of Johnson Controls Company. The two make the exact lineup of HVAC equipment, including furnaces and air conditioners.  

How Old is My Coleman Furnace?

You can determine the age of the furnace you have purchased from the serial number on the data plate. The ten-character serial number begins with one letter digit followed by a numeric one, where the year of manufacture is the second and fourth numeric digits combined. The third digit represents the month of its manufacture. 

How Do You Read a Coleman Serial Number?

The ten-character serial number begins with one letter digit followed by a numeric one, and another one-letter digit with seven numerical digits, where the year of manufacture is the second and fourth numeric digits combined. The third digit represents the month of its manufacture.

My name is Bob Wells and I am a retired HVAC tech from Washington state. I am currently retired and no longer do much with HVAC, however, I feel like I have a lot of knowledge in the subject and I wanted to create a website where I could talk about what I've learned and help upcoming HVAC techs. Find more info about me and HVAC Training 101.