Most Realistic Electric Fireplaces – 2021 Round-up

| Last Updated: July 17, 2021

A crackling fire in a beautiful fireplace in our lounge or room is something that we have all imagined for our houses. 

However, some people are not comfortable with it due to the fire hazard, environmental factor, or just don’t have the right space or it. 

Electric fireplaces are a perfect solution to all of this. They feature very realistic flames with great heat output. This article tells you all that you need to know about them. 

Comparison of the Most Realistic Electric Fireplaces

IMAGEPRODUCT
  • Comes with a variety of heat settings included
  • Will quickly and easily heat up a large space
  • Very easy to use and assemble
View Latest Price →
  • A slim design to build into the wall
  • Provides authentic crackling sounds when in use
  • Very easy to assemble and operate
View Latest Price →
  • Best for the Money
  • Comes with different heat settings for different options
  • Made from high-quality materials
View Latest Price →
  • An easy to use remote control is included
  • Quite easy to assemble the fireplace
  • Comes with a variety of heat settings
View Latest Price →
  • Stand-alone fireplace and space heater
  • Can be used for a variety of heating applications
  • Made from quality materials to be durable
View Latest Price →

Aspects to Consider Before Buying

Electric fireplaces are a rather interesting product and you will not only have fun using it but also shopping for it. However, you need to know what to look for in a quality electric fireplace. Therefore, we have outlined some of the key aspects for you. 

Flames

Even if their visual appeal is not the primary purpose of your purchase, how real the flames will look is a significant factor. It might heat up the room fast and efficiently, but if it looks fake and artificial at first glance, then there isn’t much use spending all that money. Fireplaces have a great aesthetic value, and the flames of an electric one should also represent that. 

Heat Output

After the flames, the next most important thing is to consider the heating capacity of your fireplace. You want various heat settings that not only make the space warm and cozy but should also complement the fire settings that you have chosen. This, along with the no-heat option, will allow it to run all year. 

Noise

A fireplace represents peace, serenity, and calmness. Hence, your electric fireplace should not make any loud noises that disturb the peaceful environment it is meant to create. Pay special attention to this factor, and you will thank us later.

Duraflame 3D DFI-5010-01

Review of the Most Realistic Electric Fireplaces

Now let’s move on to the section that most of you must have been waiting for. Here we have shortlisted the topmost realistic electric fireplaces. These products have been chosen after careful deliberation and have been reviewed honestly. 

Best Overall

Duraflame 3D DFI-5010-01

Duraflame 3D Infrared Electric Fireplace Stove with Remote Control - Portable Indoor Space Heater - DFI-5010 (Black)

Specifications

Decibel Level: N/A

Coverage Area: 1,000 sq ft.

Heat Output: 5,200 BTU/h

Dimensions: 13.07 x 24 x 23.4

Weight: 28.6 pounds

We may earn commission from purchases made from our links, at no additional cost to you

What Recent Buyers Report

Buyers have been absolutely delighted with the performance. Quite a few of them didn’t expect the flames to look so real. They reported that guests were even afraid to touch it for fear of getting burned. Customers found the installation process and the overall handling of the product pretty easy. Moreover, they were satisfied with its heat output and reported that it warmed the room comfortably. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

Several factors made this product stand out. One of them is the very realistic and 3D flame; customers that buy electric fireplaces are usually very keen about this feature. The flames on this unit dance around on the top, in front of, and behind the logs. They got every detail right, even down to the glowing embers. 

Moreover, this is not just a valuable addition to the décor of your home or office but also gives a year-round comfortable ambiance. Whatever the weather conditions outside, you can rely on this. Its infrared heating system maintains a healthy home environment as it doesn’t suck out all the vapors from the room and maintains its natural humidity. Lastly, this has a zone heating mechanism that falls lighter in the pocket. 

Bottom Line

This product deserved to have a place on this exclusive list. It is efficient, has an impeccable aesthetic vibe, and does the job it is designed for rather remarkably. Its high customer ratings, coupled with its awesome features, should prove enough to convince you.  

Pros

Features a flexible digital thermostat

Safety feature to prevent overheating

Has a magnificent BTU power of 5200

Comfortable, warm air without sucking

3D realistic flames with varying color, brightness, and speed settings

Cons

Return window of only 30 days

Product support expires in 60 days

Runner-up

PuraFlame EF45DFGF

PuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert with Fire Crackling Sound, Remote Control, 750/1500W, Black, 33 5/64 Inches Wide, 25 35/64 Inches High

Specifications

Decibel Level: 1500 dB

Coverage Area: 400 sq ft.

Heat Output: N/A

Dimensions: 35.04 x 8.78 x 26.99

Weight: 46.7 pounds

We may earn commission from purchases made from our links, at no additional cost to you

What Recent Buyers Report

Since it can be used with or without heat, many users bought it for décor and thoroughly enjoyed its performance. The logs and the flames shooting up from it have a very soothing and realistic effect. Another thing that customers seemed to enjoy was how it doesn’t create a lot of noise while running. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

This product gives its customer a great experience on all levels and stages, right from the unboxing until it is up and running. The installation process is extremely easy, as is the operation. Furthermore, it is an extremely reliable and durable product, as is evident from the stupendous amount of positive reviews and high ratings. 

Moreover, the heating element is also pretty decent. While it doesn’t make a room hot as it is not designed to be a primary heat source, it takes the chill out of a room and makes it cozy and comfortable. 

Lastly, although not its defining feature, the remote control is just another aspect that highlights that manufacturers go above and beyond to guarantee a convenient and comfortable experience. 

Bottom Line

If you know what you are looking for, have done your due diligence, and decide to buy this, then you will fall in love with this. While it flames won’t fool anyone, they give a pretty amazing view of an electric fireplace. Moreover, its superior performance and smart features are a deal-maker. 

Pros

Comes with a one-year warranty

Has 100% energy-saving LED technology

Features a remote control for easy usage

Allows usage with or without heat all around the year

Three different flame settings with different brightness levels

Cons

Can’t be used as a primary heat source

Doesn’t use anti-glare glass so when it is bright inside, it is hard to look inside

Best for the Money

Touchstone 80004

Touchstone 80004 - The Sideline Electric Fireplace - 50 Inch Wide - in Wall Recessed - 5 Flame Settings - Realistic 3 Color Flame - 1500/750 Watt Heater - (Black) - Log & Crystal Hearth Options

Specifications

Decibel Level: 1,500 dB

Coverage Area: 400 sq ft.

Heat Output: N/A

Dimensions: 50.4 x 5.5 x 21.5

Weight: 59 pounds

We may earn commission from purchases made from our links, at no additional cost to you

What Recent Buyers Report

Since this is a product that has to be mounted in a wall, many customers were a little reluctant about it. However, the unit’s easy installation process gave them a sigh of relief. People have been using it all year round, with or without heat, and it gives great results regardless. 

Why it Stands Out to Us

The Touchstone electric fireplace attracted us as a collective package deal. The features you get at this price are astonishing. It has great-quality construction, and its performance is top-notch and doesn’t require you to break the bank. 

It has a built-in timer, which is a very handy feature; many of us turn on a device and then forget about it. This feature ensures that you don’t overwork it and the fireplace auto-shuts when the time is over. Moreover, the remote control just adds more convenience. It features a very luxurious design, so expect a lot of compliments from guests. 

Bottom Line

To sum up, if you want an electric fireplace with good quality but are on a budget, we strongly recommend you check this out. It has great features, warms up a room to keep it nice and cozy, and is durable as well – what more are you looking for? 

Pros

Has a phenomenal heating capacity

Includes glass crystal and faux firelog

Allows an easy assembly and mounting on the wall

Can run for long hours without any issues and maintains the temperature

Very realistic flames with many different settings, intensity, and brightness

Cons

Some people found it loud

On very bright days, it might be a little hard to see the flames

Dimplex DFI2310

Dimplex Deluxe 23' Electric Fireplace Insert, Model: DFI2310, 120V, 1375W, 12.5 Amps, Black

Specifications

Decibel Level: N/A

Coverage Area: 400 sq ft.

Heat Output: N/A

Dimensions: 23.25 x 10.75 x 19.75

Weight: 33 pounds

We may earn commission from purchases made from our links, at no additional cost to you

What Recent Buyers Report

Customers have been grateful for the unit’s easy operability and boast of the convenience it has allowed them. They have also been pretty satisfied with the construction and have commented that they haven’t run into any major issues over the years.

Why it Stands Out to Us

Unmatched realism is one of the defining features of this product. Buyers that have an interest in aesthetics and the visual appeal should seriously consider this. The LED inner glow logs, pulsating ember technology, and their collective glow make it look extremely real.

Moreover, this unit’s operating cost is highly economical and comes down to an average of two cents for every hour. The heat output is also pretty great and has three settings with a no-heat option as well.

Bottom Line

The Dimplex DFI2310 is an incredible electric fireplace that does the job it was designed for rather beautifully. This unit’s aesthetic vibe is unparalleled, and the realistic glow of the flame and the logs will make you fall in love with it.

Pros

Doesn’t make a lot of noise

Allows for an easy assembly

Has a patented flame technology

Fan-forced heater disseminates air equally

Can be plugged or fitted into a standard fireplace opening

Cons

Visual appeal drops when not in use

Remote doesn’t adjust the heat or flame settings but only turns it on or off

TURBRO Suburbs TS17u

TURBRO Suburbs TS17 Compact Electric Fireplace Stove, Freestanding Stove Heater with Realistic Flame - CSA Certified - Overheating Safety Protection - for Small Spaces - 18' 1400W

Specifications

Decibel Level: 1400 dB

Coverage Area: 400 sq ft.

Heat Output: 4777 BTU/h

Dimensions: 15 x 8 x 18

Weight: 13.86 pounds

We may earn commission from purchases made from our links, at no additional cost to you

What Recent Buyers Report

Users have been highly satisfied with the performance of this unit. The fire looks real, and it has a great visual appeal, but even the heat factor is amazing. Some people actually loved it so much; they gave it as a gift to their friends. They also appreciate how it is quiet – so much so that a mic in a gaming room doesn’t pick it either.

Why it Stands Out to Us

The TS17u showcases that a lot of thought, effort, and planning went into its design and construction. First of all, its safety features are tremendous; it is CSA-certified, which means it passed a series of tests and meets all the required standards. If it is knocked over, the device shuts off automatically to avoid any accidents.

Lastly, it doesn’t get hot to the touch as the heating module is beneath the main body, so the front, back, and sides remain cool. Moreover, the heating capacity allows it to work its magic rather quickly, and it can get you to a comfortable temperature in little time. The unique and beautiful design is just a bonus that will glam up any space where you put it.

Bottom Line

To say that the TURBRO Suburbs TS17u is an extraordinary electric fireplace would not be erroneous. It delivers on all its promises and gives a great performance. Moreover, their warranty and excellent customer service department reflect their concern for their consumers.

Pros

Has a great heating capacity

Comes with a one-year warranty

Comes with multiple safety features

Features a compact yet stylish design

Quick and easy assembly and installation

Cons

Doesn’t have a remote control

Not designed for large spaces

Can You Really Find a Quality Realistic Electric Fireplace That’s Affordable?

While the common perception, especially for electronics and electric devices, is that you cannot find a quality product at a lower price, the options from our list will prove to you how that is not true. Yes, more expensive models will have more glamorous features like smoke or fire sound effects, but finding an electric fireplace that performs the basic functions exceptionally well at an affordable price is definitely possible. 

You can see from our list that we have chosen products that are not ridiculously expensive, are well within most people’s budget, and are definitely quality products. 

Many times, when you pay more for a product, you are paying for the brand logo on the front. However, with a little research and credible reviews, you can easily find an affordable quality electric fireplace. 

What Makes an Electric Fireplace More Realistic Than Others?

When you are buying an electric fireplace, you want to make sure that the flames look real and not fake; otherwise, it will ruin your room’s vibe. Below we have highlighted what makes these flames look so real and enticing.

Quality of Material 

While expensive models will generally mimic a much realistic fire, even cheaper models can get this element right. You might be taking a hit on the heating capacity, but proper implementation should give you good results.

Technology

The technology used to produce the flames or its holograms contributes a great deal to how realistic the fire would look. Some even use LED lighting to create the effect of a real fire, while others might use rotating mirrors and light. 

Fire Effect

Features like brightness, colors, and intensity can greatly alter the look of your fire and give it the tint that you want. Moreover, the speed and its ability to dance about the logs can also give a very real impact. 

Some manufacturers take even the tiniest details into account and get the burning in the log, and even the embers’ glow just right. Features like smoke or sound can also enhance the appeal but are found on higher-end products.

Perks of Getting a Realistic Electric Fireplace

A realistic electric fireplace will be one of the best things you buy for a home. Although a real wood-burning fireplace might have nostalgic value, this is actually superior to that on many fronts. Here’s how:

Hassle 

Starting and keeping up a fire in a wooden fireplace can be hard work. There is a lot of wood collecting, chopping, and vigilance required for a traditional fireplace. However, this has a very low maintenance cost and requirement and can be turned on with a button’s push – often on the remote control.

Cleanliness 

A real fire has ash, smoke, and flying away embers. Hence, the maintenance and cleanliness of the electric fireplace are actually pretty minimal. There is no smoke or residual content; hence, an occasional sweep of a dusting cloth shall be enough. Furthermore, you do not have to worry about cleaning any stuck ash from the chimneys as an electric fireplace doesn’t have these issues.

Safety

Fire hazards or chances of an accident are much lower with an electric fireplace. Moreover, many manufacturers add safety features like built-in timers, auto shut-down mechanisms, and placement of heating modules out of the way to keep any accidents to a minimum. Also, most of them have the option to turn on the flames without turning on the heat, so it can be used easily around kids and pets as well.

Cost-Effective

This might come as a surprise, but an electric fireplace saves a lot more energy due to no fuel consumption. Hence, you can expect to see a drop in your energy bills. 

Conclusion

Electric fireplaces are a great invention and alternative to wood or gas-burning fireplaces. It gives you comfort, convenience, visual appeal, and a warm and comfortable environment. This article has covered the topic at great length and tried to educate you on all aspects. We hope you found this helpful and resourceful. Happy Shopping!

People Also Ask

Although the article covers the topic holistically and from all aspects, some questions could pop into your head. Therefore, we have added this section to address queries that have troubled quite a lot of people looking to purchase an electric fireplace.  

How Do the Flames Work on an Electric Fireplace?

There is not one single mechanism to explain how flames work on an electric fireplace. They usually employ a combination of techniques to make the flames look realistic. Some may use LED lights, while others might use rotating mirrors. Many use a combination of the two.

How to Make an Electric Fireplace Look Built-in

Customers usually want to mimic a traditional fireplace perfectly when opting for an electric fireplace. Realizing this demand, many companies and manufacturers offer designs that need to be mounted in the wall and need just the right cutout for it. 

Do Electric Fireplaces Really Heat a Room?

This is a concern many customers have, and we are here to finally put it to bed. Electric fireplaces can heat up a room very efficiently without creating smoke, ash, or any harmful emissions. The key is to know that the model you are buying is designed to heat up how big of a room. Once you figure that out, you are good to go.



My name is Bob Wells and I am a retired HVAC tech from Washington state. I am currently retired and no longer do much with HVAC, however, I feel like I have a lot of knowledge in the subject and I wanted to create a website where I could talk about what I've learned and help upcoming HVAC techs. Find more info about me and HVAC Training 101.