Kenmore Water Heater Reviews: 2019 Guide

Hot water is something we tend to take for granted, except when it’s no longer available in the house. Some homes depend on water heaters to heat up the whole building, while others use it only for hot water in the kitchen and bathroom.

If you’ve noticed leaks or strange noises in your water heater and are suspecting possible failure, or are on the lookout for a new water heater, consider the Kenmore line of water heaters. We’ll walk you through the pros and cons of this renowned brand of water heaters and suggest some models that you should consider.

The Best of Kenmore Water Heaters

Over its 100 years of history, Kenmore has delivered high quality and innovation to hundreds of millions of customers. It is the most awarded brand in the appliances industry and has received numerous awards, including the Consumers Digest Best Buy Award, 32 awards, as well as 5 Women’s Choice Awards from 2014 to 2018.

This is an indicator of the excellent reception from buyers and homeowners who have used Kenmore appliances. You can be confident of having a good experience when you purchase a Kenmore branded appliance.

Complete Buyers Guide

In case you’re having a tough time figuring out what Kenmore product is right for you, we have good news. Kenmore has a brand and product buying guide on its website, which explains the characteristics of each product line and the features you can expect. Because not every customer is looking for the same features and price points, not every Kenmore product line will be best for you.

Using their buying guide can point you in the right direction for the product or appliance that you want for your home.

Kenmore has a B2B Platform

For people looking to partner with Kenmore, their B2B platform KenmoreDirect™ offers features suitable for builders and property managers. Kenmore offers services like full delivery and installation, flexible credit options and a dedicated account manager.

This platform helps Kenmore stand out as a brand from the competition, giving it an advantage in gaining loyal corporate customers while enabling builders and property managers to meet with Kenmore and have possible contracts.


One of the queries a lot of consumers have is whether their product will be backed by a solid warranty. Kenmore offers a limited warranty for their products, and depending on the product, the period of the warranty can vary from 6 to 12 years. This is slightly higher than the average brand warranty of three to twelve years.

You will need to provide the proof of sale to claim this warranty, and there are certain conditions for the warranty. For water heaters, the warranty coverage applies when it is correctly connected, installed, operated and maintained according to the Kenmore instructions.

Thanks to its solid warranty and relatively easy claims process, buyers of Kenmore water heaters can rest easy, knowing that the manufacturer will help them out in case something goes wrong with their purchase.

Smart Technology

One concern that homeowners have is that their water heater can leak while they are out of the house, causing flooding and expensive damage. But Kenmore has a nifty solution for this as well.

A few models of Kenmore water heaters are compatible with Kenmore Smart Water Heater Module, which has wi-fi connectivity for remote monitoring, control and leak detection from your smartphone. This system will ensure that you are alerted remotely when a leak takes place, allowing you to get the problem fixed before major damage occurs. Using the free Kenmore Smart App, you can have full remote control of your hot water heater.

In the highly connected world we live in today, such innovations can really make life easier for us, and Kenmore is always at the forefront of such useful inventions in home appliances. Whether it’s turning the heater off remotely to save utility costs or getting warned about leaks, this type of “smart device” is sure to make life more convenient.

A Slight Complaint on Kenmore Water Heaters

While most Kenmore water heaters run just fine, some owners have complained about their water heaters leaking after a few years of operation. You should keep this fact in mind when shopping for a new water heater and always check consumer reviews about a particular model that you may be considering.

Leakages can be caused by defects in the system, or by improperly installed equipment. So to avoid the latter, always choose a reputable licensed professional to perform the installation of your water heaters.

Types of Kenmore Water Heaters

Kenmore water heaters are available in electric, hybrid, liquid propane, and natural gas-powered variants. Each type of heater is suitable for certain applications and homes.

These water heaters come with features like a glass-lined tank and foam insulation, which help to ward off corrosion and heat loss, thus ensuring maximum performance.


Electric water heaters have a few advantages over gas water heaters. Electric heaters have no chance of a gas leak and don’t require a pilot light, preventing the inconvenience of relighting the flame. Installing an electric water heater is easier and faster than gas heaters, and in general is much cheaper to install. Electric water heaters generally last longer than gas water heaters, providing you with good value for money.


Hybrid water heaters use a heat pump to pull heat from the air to heat the water. It works like a refrigerator in reverse and cools the area surrounding the tank. When a lot of hot water is needed at once, the hot water heater switches to electric heat to fulfill the extra needs. This combination of heating technologies allows for more energy efficiency, saving you money in the long run.

Kenmore hybrid water heaters are also compatible with the Kenmore Smart Water Heater Module, which connects your smartphone to your heater, giving you remote control capabilities.


Kenmore gas-powered water heaters also have some advantages over their water heaters. For example, they heat water around twice as fast as electric water heaters, which is ideal for large families. They are available in a wide range of sizes and capacities, from 30 to 98 gallons. Unlike electric heaters, a gas water heater is still operable during periods of no power.

Liquid propane

One big advantage of liquid propane hot water heaters is that they typically use even less energy than electric water heaters. Kenmore liquid propane water heaters have thick insulation to keep the tank warm, while the cobalt-blue glass lining protects the tank from corrosion.

Top Sellers

Kenmore 58250 Electric water heater

This 50-gallon water heater meets the minimum recommended size for a 3- to 4-person household with typical water use. It has three inches of foam insulation for better thermal efficiency and a long-life baked enamel exterior finish. The elements on this Kenmore electric water heater are designed to combat lime build-up.

It also features a polymer dip tube, a Cobalt blue glass-lined tank, and 2 large anode rods for protection against corrosion. The tank and parts have a 12-year limited warranty. Self-cleaning cold-water inlet tube swirls the water to prolong tank life and maintain energy efficiency by discouraging lime buildup and comes with built-in temperature and pressure safety relief valve. This heater is compatible with the Kenmore Smart Water Heater Module for smartphone remote control.

Kenmore 33176 Natural gas water heater

This 74-gallon water heater is designed for a household of up to 5 people with normal water usage. It runs on natural gas and uses thick foam insulation to prevent corrosion and heat loss.

The cobalt blue Ultra Coat™ glass-lined tank comes with an anode rod to protect the tank from corrosion. The self-cleaning RotoSwirl cold water inlet tube reduces mineral buildup, and the factory-installed temperature and pressure safety relief valve ensure your family is safe.

Choose this water heater if you have a larger household where fast water heating is needed due to several people using hot water in one go.

Kenmore 57941 Natural gas water heater

The Kenmore 57941 has a 40-gallon tank capacity and runs on natural gas. A 40-gallon natural gas water heater is the minimum recommended size for a 2- to 4-person household with typical water use.

It uses 2 inches of foam insulation for energy efficiency and has a cobalt blue glass-lined tank with a large anode rod to protect the tank from corrosion. It also includes a self-cleaning cold water inlet tube that reduces and protects against mineral build-up in the tank. It has a 9-year warranty on tank and parts. Like the other water heaters in this list, it comes with factory-installed temperature and pressure relief valve.

Go for this option if you have a small household with limited hot water needs.

How to Know your Water Heater is About to Fail

You can often tell that your water heater is about to give out before the failure actually happens. Here are some common signs to watch out for.

Lack of Hot Water

One of the first signs of an impending water heater failure is the lack of sufficient hot water. Over time, mineral deposits from the water can build up in the tank as sediment, and create a barrier between the burner and the water. It means that the heater’s effectiveness decreases, and your heater heating element has to work harder. It is not only costly in terms of fuel or energy but also hastens the failure of your heater.

Popping or Rumbling Noises

Another sign of possible water heater failures about to happen is creaking or rumbling noises. These noises can be caused by hard water and mineral buildup, or as the minerals form a layer on the surface of the water heater. The rumbling sound is caused by pockets of air in the sediment layer boiling along with the water in your tank.

Minor leaks

Small leaks are often a sign of upcoming major leaks and possibly expensive repairs. If you notice water around your water heater, or if it leaks when standing, chances are that your heater´s inner tank is close to the end. These slow leaks can quickly turn into big leaks, potentially causing a flood.

As soon as you suspect that your water heater is about to fail, you should call in a professional to thoroughly check it out. Early and prompt action can save you a lot of money from flood damage and repairs.

Kenmore Water Heater History

The brand Kenmore first appeared on sewing machines in 1913 and was introduced by Sears, Roebuck, and Co. The brand soon appeared on more home appliances, and after WWII the Kenmore offered the latest home items that every homeowner would need in their kitchen. The brand stood out from others by offering appliances in various colors.

Over time, the company continued to offer novel and useful products to help make everyday chores a little easier, ranging from countertop appliances to vacuum cleaners.

Kenmore is the number one manufacturer of home appliances in the industry today. Kenmore is exclusively available at Sears and is ranked in either the number one or number two spot in every major appliance that they sell.


Now that you know the background of Kenmore products and what sort of features they offer in their water heater range, you are well positioned to make an informed decision about whether Kenmore water heaters are right for you. Keep in mind the warranty offered, the kind of water heater (gas-electric or hybrid) you will need as well as the extra features such as smartphone-based control offered. Also factor in the price and capacity of the water tank into your decision making. Happy buying!

Leave a Comment